CIS 6930 Spring 26

Logo

Data Engineering at the University of Florida

Peer Review Rubrics

This course uses calibrated peer review for grading. These rubrics guide both reviewers and authors.

Assignment Rubrics

Rubric Used For Points When
Assignment 0 Rubric Assignment 0: API Data Collection 50 Week 2
Assignment Rubric Assignment 1 and later Varies Weeks 3+

Project Rubrics

Rubric Used For Points When
Proposal Rubric Project proposals 100 Week 4
Design Rubric Design documents 100 Week 6
Code Rubric Code checkpoints 150 Week 10
Paper Rubric Draft and final papers 100 / 400 Week 11 / 13
Presentation Rubric Final presentations 150 Week 14

Review Quality

Rubric Used For When
Feedback Quality Rubric Grading peer review quality All assignments
Meta-Review Rubric Authors evaluating reviews received All assignments

How Peer Review Works

Review Process

  1. Submission - Teams submit artifacts by deadline
  2. Assignment - Each submission receives 3 reviewers
  3. Review - Reviewers evaluate using the rubric
  4. Discussion - Authors can respond to reviews
  5. Meta-Review - Authors rate review quality
  6. Scoring - Final scores computed from reviews

Calibration

Before reviewing peer work, you will complete calibration exercises:

Review Quality Score

Your review quality is evaluated on:

This contributes to the 10% “Review Quality” portion of your grade.

Review Ethics

Do

Don’t

back